So, Stefan Draminski's statements claiming that the limitations of space were the reason for the shortcomings listed are very wrong. (I think someone posted a computer generated image on showing this feature.)" Yet the would be the very type of detail that does not show up well in 2D but could be illustrated in 3D.
In the other turrets you can walk all the way around. Similarly, if you go down to turret one at the powder flat, the powder passing ring does not go all the way around because the turret support bends inward to account for the narrowness of the hull. The errors show up making things in 3D incorrectly. Thus, if they had just copied the BGP and left it in 2D there would be no error. If climb down there on the ships, you find these lines are outlines of the keel plating. If you look at the BGP for the Iowa class ships and take a look at the hold level at the bow. The odd thing is that the 3D brings out many of the errors. I've seen other renderings in which you can see the vertical arrangement of the deck. I'm not sure if this is because of they way the renderings are oriented or because the underlying model is wrong. I can't tell anything about the vertical arrangement of the decks from the them. These may look cool in 3d but they are wrong. They omit the hull castings and replace them with framing. They show intake trunks where no such trunks exist. Go into the uptake spaces in the superstructure and there are no decks. Climb down the ladder from the second deck to the aviation fuel tanks and you find there is no deck just walkways attached to the framing. In the case of the AOTS Iowa, the internal renderings are frequently wrong in key details. The renderings-in-place-of-photos are inherently inaccurate because some details (that would show up in photos) are omitted. For something the scale of a battleship it would take a lifetime to do fully accurate 3D model.
AOTS has become a 3D rendering series.ģD renderings are great for illustrating concepts but they suck as an alternative to photographs. Steve Smith posted the following on Steelnavy Board on July 24 in a thread discussing the forthcoming AotS Scharnhorst by the same Draminski:"Your view of them is better than mine but you express the problem.
0 kommentar(er)
